Garbage - Cities in Dust lyrics

Garbage's cover of "Cities in Dust" has elicited a wide range of responses from fans and listeners around the world. Many have praised the band for their interpretation, expressing admiration for Shirley Manson's powerful vocals, the killer guitar work, the hard-hitting bass, and the fast, loud drums. Comments such as "Amazing cover, Shirley sounds awesome" and "Garbage did this great song justice" highlight the positive reception of the band's rendition.

Furthermore, fans have applauded the band's ability to capture the essence of the original song while infusing it with their own unique style. One comment states, "This is exactly what a cover should do. It's different, and that's how it should be." Others have emphasized the political interpretation presented in the music video, praising Garbage for providing a fresh perspective in these times of global change.

However, amidst the praise, there are contrasting opinions and criticisms. Some listeners argue that the cover fails to bring anything new to the original song, stating that "Garbage brings nothing to it at all" and that the band should stick to their own music. This perspective suggests that the cover lacks the brilliance found in the original version by Siouxsie and the Banshees.

Garbage's rendition of "Cities in Dust" is commended for its dark and haunting sound, which pays homage to Siouxsie and the Banshees' post-punk roots. Shirley Manson's vocals are widely praised, with comments like "Shirley Manson has been, is, and always will be hot" and "Shirley's voice is amazing still." Listeners appreciate her ability to infuse the song with emotion and intensity, creating a captivating experience.

The instrumentation in the cover is also a point of discussion. While many appreciate the industrial and aggressive elements, some find fault with the guitar work, describing it as "too abrasive" and "rough." These critiques emphasize the subjective nature of musical preferences, where what appeals to one listener may not resonate with another.